As
we enter 2011 let it bring to us and all of our families all peace,
good health, and prosperity, if only in your mind. 2010 has been for all
of us very trying and frightening as we continue to watch as our country
spirals down this path of destruction. It seems that we are helpless to
do anything about it as we see scheme after scheme fail. Not one to live
in the past as there is very little that can be done to change the
past. Never the less it is to the past that we must look for lessons
learned in order to reduce our repetition of the same strategic and tactical
errors. We must look positively to the future; as it is always
what we make it, and this is a conclusion that I came to many years ago.
With that said I am confident that as the norm many challenges will come
our way, so at minimum, one should be mentally prepared to face these
inevitable events.
One
such event is the continued increase in crime and violence in our
society, sorry if you were expecting to hear of a reduction in criminality
in The Bahamas. The present approach to crime management plays a
pivotal role in this statement more than the affects that we see around
us. For clarity I am not talking about the murders, robberies, assaults
rapes etc. Rather the attempt to reduce crime by addressing the
judiciary and police, as opposed to an all out attack of the social ills
that cause crime.
What appears to be missing or lacking from our
society is an aggressive approach to reducing juvenile delinquency,
which when left to fester evolves into the adult categorization we call
crime. It is bewildering that Government Ministries such as Education,
Social Services, Sports, Youth and Culture are not receiving more
funding, aid, and restructuring as a part of a national crime prevention
program.
The current philosophy of increased police and security
presence, alarm systems, burglar bars, reduce cash on premises are all
response to crime, not prevention. If one is to compare crime and social
disobedience to a disease then the aforementioned ministries can be
said to be the preventative and wellness programs; whereas the,
surveillance systems, tracing anklets, law enforcement and the courts
are likened to pills, emergency medicine, and surgery.
For
example in the last 10 years we have seen more shifts, reassignments,
restructuring in the Police and Judiciary than in all 5 agencies
combined.
It is painfully obvious that the problem is not the
fruit which we are attempting to lock up and give harsher sentence to
but the tree i.e. our social and cultural infrastructure.
What
is wrong with the way the Police fight crime will be left for part 2 of
this forecast, as during this writing I am focusing on the causation
factors as opposed to reactive measures.
Education
We may question if the education system is failing, and it becomes a national debate when
the results of the BGCSE and BJC are released. This argument has very
far reaching ramifications that go beyond our nation's ability to compete
with the global marketplace as it tries to prove it has a qualified and deep pool of
employable persons. It reflects our ability to communicated and relate
to each other. Where there is a breakdown in communication, there is
confusion, which leads to frustration, anger, and violence.
Rationale
and problem solving skills are greatly diminished because little Johnny
cannot read. After several attempts to save money by purchasing an off
market product only to find that the instructions are in every language
but English, I have decided to stick with those products that have
English as it's a primary form of communication.
Of course
the issue here is not the savings but the frustration in not being able
to understand what was required. The low level of education speaks to
the inability of persons to receive instructions, but also their
difficulty in understanding these directions. Out of unintended shame
and embarrassment, many times too many a violent response is given.
‘Boys
will be boys,’ says the mother as her son is arrested for the third time
for being in possession of marijuana. This is a truth that should not be
laughed at, but used to our advantage by creating more boys and girls
only schools. It appears to me that many of young men and women are
distracted and need assistance in prioritizing what is necessary for the
various stages in their life.
Studies have shown that
there are noticeable changes in behavior and better academic performance
when troubled young men are placed in a male only environment.
Additionally we must realize, as if the need to bring in over 8,000
Chinese laborers that not everyone is inclined to be a doctor, lawyer or
scientist. We must find other alternatives such as masons, carpenters
and mechanics that should be taught from junior high.
Social Services
What
exactly is the role of social services in reducing crimes, how can they
help? Well my experience with young men and women tells me that they
are receiving another type of education besides the formal lessons in
school. The ‘school of hard knocks’ regularly reminds these kids that
they will not always have food to eat, uniforms to wear, or worse, mommy or
daddy to give them the love they need. It easy for those of us who have
emotional, educational, and financial backing to sit on the side and
critique, demand longer jail terms and hangings, but are we really addressing
the problem? Let's be real Bahamas, we all need love and desire to be
loved to make it through the day. With this ‘love’ to look forward to
then really what is there to lose?
Here I see the social
worker as more than someone who hands out food stamps or is able to find
shelter for the less fortunate, but someone who can tap into that inner
being and facilitate via church or some other civic group where help
needed.
Sports
The
social skill one learns from playing sports is terribly under-rated and
needs to be harnessed immediately. Team and individual sports, besides
fostering health lifestyles, teach discipline, respect, patience,
confidence, cooperation, to name a few; which are fundamental characteristics
lacking in many of us today. I am convinced that organized sports
programs are one of the most powerful weapons that we have to fighting
and reducing crime. Be it tennis, swimming, golf, any of the martial
arts discipline, track and field; we are missing the learning and molding
opportunities that these physical and mental disciplines offer. Let’s
not get confused, the purpose here is not to create world champions but
better Bahamians.
Youth
Forgive
my ignorance, but what exactly does this ministry do aside from
organizing an annual youth march? If we sincerely believe in the
statements that ‘children are the future’ and ‘children are the wealth
of a nation’, then this division of government must receive more
attention, planning, and investment. The primary focus of which must be
in the young men. I am not chauvinist but I firmly believe that the man
is the fundamental backbone to a healthy society.
Where we
have seen the decline in good male leadership we have seen a direct
increase in moral decay and crime. No I did not conduct a research or hire
some consultant, I just live here. What amazes me is that already in
place are groups such as the Boy’s Brigade and Boys Scouts that can cater
to this training of our young men, but they lack the funding. Boy’s need
to be taught how to be men and lead, we can't hope for it to happen without
seriously placing effort into the process. Think about it... who are the
main perpetrators of social disorder and crimes? We all know the answer,
but yet we are not attempting to get to the source.
Culture
The
identity crisis being experienced in our country has in my opinion been a
major catalyst to the social and moral decay we are currently
experiencing. Frankly, if you do not know who you are then nothing and no
one really matters. What is worse is when an individual is left to
discover what his / her purpose is, on their own. This hit and miss
approach to self discovery is extremely dangerous and wasteful. We must
remember that we are losing lives, not money or some other property.
A strong cultural appreciation is key to fostering a strong national
pride, where a greater sense of ownership is instilled. This approach to
crime reduction makes the Bahamian more than a caretaker, but a
stakeholder. This taps into the survivalist nature that we all have when
it comes to protecting our own. It brings to life again the chorus
‘this land is my land, this land is your land’ come to life again.
This
may be seem as an unusual way to start crime reduction initiatives,
but in my opinion it gets to root causes, with specific attempts to kill
the seeds that grow into the chaotic and frightening lives we are living now. For this refocusing to be successful it requires that all of the
aforementioned areas be addressed. It cannot only be education, as we
must approach the crime reduction effort from all angles.
We are however
placing too much focus and emphasis on the end result. When we see past
and present governments spending millions on new court buildings,
police cars and physical infrastructure, it becomes painfully clear that we are playing a game of wait and see. What makes
matters worst is boasting of a high detection rate or that most crimes are being committed by repeat offenders. We
should not be excited about hanging offenders when we put so
little effort into the understanding and the curbing of the desires our people have to commit these
crimes.
Gamal Newry is the
President of Preventative Measures, a Loss Prevention and Asset
Protection Training and Consulting Company, specializing in Policy and
Procedure Development, Business Security Reviews and Audits, &
Emergency and Crisis Management. Comments can be sent to P.O. Box N-3154
Nassau, Bahamas or, email info@preventativemeasures.net or visit us at www.preventativemeasures.net